Efficient cqi signaling in multi-beam mimo systems

ABSTRACT

The present invention relates to the signaling of channel quality information in a multi-beam transmission system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams. Determined are beams with a different quality resulting in different effects of errors in the transmissions of the channel quality information for the beams. Said different effects are exploited for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the beams.

The present invention relates to a method for signaling channel quality information in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO (multiple-in/multiple-out) system. Moreover, the present invention relates to a computer program product for carrying out the method. Further, the present invention relates to a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information (CQI) are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams. Still further, the present invention relates to a network element, in particular a node, in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams. Still further, the present invention relates to a user equipment, in particular a mobile station, in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams. Finally, the present invention relates to a signal for indicating channel quality information in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams.

The present invention can be applied in multi-antenna communication systems. In particular, a potential application of the present invention is in the MIMO feature currently being standardized for UMTS (universal mobile telecommunication system) Release 7.

In the third generation partnership project (3GPP) a proposal called D-TxAA is under discussion for UMTS as a way of increasing the peak bit rate. This is derived from an existing closed loop transmit diversity scheme (TxAA mode 1) where the mobile terminal signals to the network complex weights which should be applied to the signals from each of two transmitting antennas. In D-TxAA two different data streams are transmitted using orthogonal weight vectors, wherein a first weight vector is based on those transmitted from the mobile terminal, and a second vector is derived deterministically from the first vector.

For the operation of D-TxAA, the following may be assumed:

Orthogonal pilot channels are transmitted from an antenna of each Node B (which is a logical node responsible for radio transmission and reception in one or more cells to and from an user equipment (UE).

No dedicated (i.e. beam formed) pilots are available (assuming that the fractional dedicated physical channel (F-DPCH) is used, which does not carry pilot bits).

Feedback information (FBI) for the first beam is derived by the user equipment (UE) and transmitted to Node B, indicating the desired beamforming vector.

The first beam is transmitted using a restricted codebook of weight vectors (for example the codebook currently used for TxAA mode 1).

The identity of the antenna weight vector for a first beam is signaled to the UE on the High-Speed Shared Control Channel (HS-SCCH).

The second beam is transmitted using a deterministic phase vector, which is orthonormal to the vector for the first beam.

Channel quality information (CQI) is signaled by the UE to the Node B, enabling the Node B to derive a different rate for each of the two beams.

The CQI indicates the rate (or packet size) which can be transmitted successfully (or with a given probability of success) using a reference power level and code resource (the reference values being known by both the network and the mobile terminal).

The transmissions on the two beams are comprised of separate codewords with potentially different rates.

As the simultaneously transmitted beams in D-TxAA are typically received with different SINR (signal-to-noise ratio where the noise includes both thermal noise and interference) at the UE, each beam can support a correspondingly different rate. This implies that multiple CQI information is required to be signaled to the Node B by each UE. In UMTS Release 5, a single CQI value is comprised of 5 information bits, coded into 20 physical channel bits. For a multiple-beam system, this number of bits would be multiplied by the number of beams if a separate CQI value is indicated for every beam. This can result in a high signaling load.

An object of the present invention is to reduce the CQI signaling load in multi-beam systems.

In order to achieve the above and further objects, in accordance with a first aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method for signaling channel quality information in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, comprising the steps of determining beams with different quality, and exploiting said different qualities for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the beams.

In accordance with a second aspect of the present invention, there is provided a computer program for carrying out the method according to the first aspect of the present invention.

In accordance with a third aspect of the present invention, there is provided a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, comprising a determining device for determining beams with different quality, and an exploiting device for exploiting said different qualities for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the beams.

In accordance with a fourth aspect of the present invention, there is provided a network element, in particular a node, in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, comprising a determining device for determining beams with different quality, and an exploiting device for exploiting said different qualities for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the beams.

In accordance with a fifth aspect of the present invention, there is provided a user equipment, in particular a mobile station, in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, comprising a determining device for determining beams with different quality, and an exploiting device for exploiting said different qualities for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the beams.

In accordance with a sixth aspect of the present invention, there is provided a signal for indicating channel quality information in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, the signal comprising a reduced overhead of channel quality information for the beams, based on exploiting differences in qualities of the beams.

The present invention leads to a reduction of the CQI signaling load in multi-beam transmission systems. This advantage is achieved in particular by that according to the present invention the different effects of errors in the CQI transmissions for the different beams which effects result from different quality of the beams are exploited for using signaling overhead of CQI for the multiple beams.

Further advantageous embodiments are defined in the dependent claims.

Preferably, said determining device is adapted to determine beams with different quality resulting in different effects of errors in the transmissions of the channel quality information for the beams, and in particular said determining device is adapted to determine a primary beam with a higher quality and at least one secondary beam with a lower quality in the plurality of beams resulting in different effects of errors in the channel quality information transmissions for the secondary beam(s).

There may be a differential signaling device for providing a differential signaling for indicating the channel quality information value for the secondary beam(s). The differential signaling device may be adapted to signal an absolute value of the channel quality information for the primary beam, and the channel quality information values for the secondary beam(s) by means of an offset relative to the value for the primary beam. Further, the differential signaling device may be adapted to derive the offset from an average difference in quality between the respective secondary beam and the primary beam.

Preferably, the exploiting device may be adapted to provide different update rates for the channel quality information for different beams, wherein the differential signaling device may be adapted to signal the offset at a lower update rate than the absolute channel quality information value for the primary beam. Further, the exploiting device may be adapted to provide a lower update rate for the channel quality information transmissions relating to the secondary beam(s) compared to the update rate for the channel quality information transmissions relating to the primary beam. The update rates may be signaled from a network element, in particular a node, to a user equipment, and may be predetermined.

Preferably, the exploiting device is adapted to provide different cut-off thresholds, below which a reporting of channel quality information is not required, for different beams, and in particular the exploiting device is adapted to provide a higher cut-off threshold for the secondary beam(s) than for the primary beam. The cut-off thresholds may be signaled from a network element, in particular a node, to a user equipment, and may be predetermined Further, scheduled time instants are provided for the user equipment to transmit channel quality information to the network element, and when user equipment estimates that the channel quality for a beam is below the respective cut-off threshold for that beam, the user equipment does not transmit channel quality information at the scheduled time instants until the channel quality is above the respective cut-off threshold. Moreover, according to a preferred embodiment, wherein when the network element does not receive channel quality information at a scheduled time instant it does not make any further transmissions on the respective beam(s) until it receives a different channel quality information value from the user equipment.

Preferably, the exploiting device is adapted to provide different channel quality information quantization granularities for different beams. The exploiting device may be adapted to provide a coarser channel quality information quantization granularity for the secondary beam(s) compared to the channel quality information quantization granularity applied to the channel quality information reports for the primary beam. Further, the exploiting device may be adapted to apply the coarser channel quality information quantization granularity for the secondary beam(s) only to a lower part of the channel quality information range. A network element, in particular a node, may be provided to instruct a user equipment to use different channel quality information quantization granularities for different beams. Still further, the channel quality information quantization granularities may be predetermined

Preferably, an encoding device is provided for jointly encoding the channel quality information values transmitted for more than one beam into a single codeword for transmission from a user equipment to a network element, in particular a node.

It is recognized that in D-TxAA systems a first beam is typically always of better quality than a second beam as the beam forming weights for the first beam are specifically designed to optimize the signal-to-interference ratio (SIR) of the first beam, while the beam forming weights for the second beam are derived deterministically from the first beam.

In general, multi-beam transmission systems can be considered to be comprised of a primary beam with an optimized SIR and one or more secondary beams with a lower SIR.

Consequently, the effect of errors in the CQI signaling for the secondary beam(s) is considered to be less significant than the effect of errors in the CQI signaling for the primary beam, when considering the total achievable transmission rate over all the beams. This results in a different effect of errors in the CQI transmissions for the secondary beam(s). Therefore, at first, a primary beam and one or more secondary beams are determined among the multiple beams.

Then, the different effects of errors in the CQI transmissions for the secondary beam(s) are exploited for reducing a signaling overhead of CQI for the multiple beams.

Preferably, the exploiting of the different effects can include one or more of the following three measures or steps:

1. A different (typically lower) update rate is provided for the CQI transmissions relating to at least one secondary beam compared to the update rate for the CQI transmissions relating to the primary beam. These update rates are signaled to the UE by the Node B. In a typical embodiment, a rate of CQI reporting is signaled for the primary beam, and one or more further (advantageously lower) update rates are signaled for one or more secondary beams. In some embodiments, the one or more further update rates may be signaled by means of a divisor of the rate signaled for the primary beam. In a variation of this embodiment, the update rate for CQI transmissions is optionally selected depending upon the rate of change of the channel on each beam. 2. A different (typically higher) cut-off threshold is provided for one or more beams, below which the UE should not report CQI values for the respective beams. In the prior art, an “out-of-range” CQI value is provided for transmission by the UE when the SIR is too low for the UE successfully to decode any of the available transmission formats. However, transmission of such a value continues to contribute to an uplink signaling overhead, even when no data can be received on the downlink. In order to reduce the signaling overhead, the Node B signals to the UE a cut-off CQI level for one or more beams, below which the UE ceases to report CQI for that beam, and the Node B makes no further transmissions on such beams until it receives from the UE another CQI value. In a variation of this embodiment particularly suited to cases where a fixed number of bits is allocated in the uplink signaling channel for CQI reporting purposes, the proportion of the fixed number of uplink bits available for CQI reports is varied according to beam quality, such that when one or more beams have an “out of range” CQI and hence no CQI report is sent, more CQI bits for the “in range” beam(s) may be sent instead to improve their quantization and/or reliability. 3. A different (typically coarser) CQI quantization granularity is provided for at least one secondary beam compared to the CQI quantization granularity applied to the CQI reports for the primary beam. If the rate of the secondary beam(s) is lower and therefore the total rate is less sensitive to errors in the CQI for the secondary beam(s), it is more efficient to coarsen the granularity of the CQI reporting for those beams whereby the number of required signaling bits is reduced. For example, while a 1 dB granularity is typically applied for a primary beam, the Node B might use signaling to instruct the UE to use a coarser granularity (e.g. 2 dB) for one or more secondary beams. Alternatively, the granularities could be predetermined in the specification. In a further embodiment, the coarser granularity for a secondary beam could apply only to a lower part of the CQI range. In a variation of this embodiment, the range of CQI values to be transmitted for the secondary beam(s) may be different from the range of CQI values to be transmitted for the primary beam; the granularity for each beam may optionally then be the same. For example, the total range of possible CQI values could be split into a number of sub-ranges, and a UE would signal only a CQI value within a beam's current sub-range. In an extension of this embodiment, special CQI values could be reserved to indicate switching up or down to the next sub-range of CQI values. Sub-ranges might further be designed to overlap, or be extended or reduced or otherwise adapted by further signaling in order to optimize them for the current beams and channel conditions.

In any of the embodiments, the CQI values transmitted for more than one beam can be jointly encoded into a single codeword for transmission to the Node B.

Differential signaling may be used to indicate the CQI value for one or more secondary beams. For example, an absolute value of CQI may be signaled for the primary beam, and the CQI values for one or more secondary beams may be signaled by means of an offset relative to the value for the primary beam. In particular, the offset can be signaled at a lower update rate than the absolute CQI value for the primary beam. In further embodiments, the offset can be derived from an average difference in quality between the respective secondary beam and the primary beam, wherein the averaging period can be e.g. related to the update rate of the primary beam CQI value, related to the update rate of the offset, predetermined, signaled to the UE by the Node B, or signaled to the Node B by the UE.

Such a difference in CQI may be in terms of a transmission power offset which is required between a secondary beam and the primary beam, assuming that both beams would be transmitted with the same modulation and coding scheme. Alternatively the difference in CQI may be in terms of a transmission power offset required under the assumption that the secondary beam is transmitted with a fixed difference (or ratio) in the data rate relative to the primary beam.

Differential signaling for CQI is typically advantageous if the CQI values of different beams are correlated to a certain extent. In a variation of the embodiments using differential signaling, the UE therefore measures and subtracts the correlated part of the CQI values of the different beams and transmits only a value relating to the non-correlated part of the CQI for secondary beam(s) relative to a primary beam. The period over which the correlation is measured can be selected in a similar way to the averaging period.

Although the invention has been described primarily in relation to transmissions from base stations to mobile terminals, the invention is also applicable to transmissions from mobile terminals to base stations, and between peer nodes.

In the present specification and claims the word “a” or “an” preceding an element does not exclude the presence of a plurality of such elements. Further, the word “comprising” does not exclude the presence of other elements or steps than those listed.

From reading the present disclosure, other modifications will be apparent to persons skilled in the art. Such modifications may involve other features which are already known in the art of radio communication and which may be used instead of or in addition to features already described herein. 

1. A method for signaling channel quality information in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, comprising the steps of: determining different beams with different qualities; and reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the beams depending on the different qualities of the different beams.
 2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the step of determining beams with different qualities comprises determining different beams with different qualities resulting in different effects of errors in the transmissions of the channel quality information for the beams.
 3. The method according to claim 2, wherein in said determining step a primary beam with a higher quality and at least one secondary beam with a lower quality is determined in the plurality of beams resulting in different effects of errors in the channel quality information transmissions for the secondary beam(s).
 4. The method according to claim 1, wherein a differential signaling is used to indicate the channel quality information value for the secondary beam(s).
 5. The method according to claim 4, wherein an absolute value of the channel quality information is signaled for the primary beam, and the channel quality information values for the secondary beam(s) are signaled by means of an offset relative to the value for the primary beam.
 6. The method according to claim 4, wherein the offset is derived from an average difference in quality between the respective secondary beam and the primary beam.
 7. The method according to claim 1, wherein in said exploiting step different update rates for the channel quality information are provided for different beams.
 8. The method according to claim 5, wherein the offset is signaled at a lower update rate than the absolute channel quality information value for the primary beam.
 9. The method according to claim 3, wherein a lower update rate for the channel quality information transmissions relating to the secondary beam(s) compared to the update rate for the channel quality information transmissions relating to the primary beam is provided.
 10. The method according to claim 7, wherein the update rates are signaled from a network element, in particular a node, to a user equipment.
 11. The method according to claim 7, wherein the update rates are predetermined.
 12. The method according to claim 1, wherein in said exploiting step different cut-off thresholds, below which a reporting of channel quality information is not required, are provided for different beams.
 13. The method according to claim 3, wherein a higher cut-off threshold is provided for the secondary beam(s) than for the primary beam.
 14. The method according to claim 12, wherein the cut-off thresholds are signaled from a network element, in particular a node, to a user equipment, in particular a mobile station.
 15. The method according to claim 12, wherein the cut-off thresholds are predetermined.
 16. The method according to claim 12, wherein scheduled time instants are provided for the user equipment to transmit channel quality information to the network element, and when the user equipment estimates that the channel quality for a beam is below the respective cut-off threshold for that beam, the user equipment does not transmit channel quality information at the scheduled time instants until the channel quality is above the respective cut-off threshold.
 17. The method according to claim 12, wherein when the network element does not receive channel quality information at a scheduled time instant it does not make any further transmissions on the respective beam(s) until it receives a different channel quality information value from the user equipment.
 18. The method according to claim 1, wherein in said exploiting step different channel quality information quantization granularities are provided for different beams.
 19. The method according to claim 3, wherein a coarser channel quality information quantization granularity is provided for the secondary beam(s) compared to the channel quality information quantization granularity applied to the channel quality information reports for the primary beam.
 20. The method according to claim 19, wherein the coarser channel quality information quantization granularity for the secondary beam(s) only applies to a lower part of the channel quality information range.
 21. The method according to claim 18, wherein a network element, in particular a node, instructs a user equipment, in particular a mobile station, to use different channel quality information quantization granularities for different beams.
 22. The method according to claim 18, wherein the channel quality information quantization granularities are predetermined.
 23. The method according to claim 1, wherein the channel quality information values transmitted for more than one beam are jointly encoded into a single codeword for transmission from a user equipment, in particular a mobile station, to a network element, in particular a node.
 24. A media encoded with a non-transitory computer readable medium for controlling a processor for carrying out a method according to claim
 1. 25. A multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, comprising: a determining device for determining different beams with different qualities; and a reducing device for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the beams depending on the determined different beams with different qualities.
 26. A network element, in particular a node, in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, comprising: a determining device for determining different beams with different qualities; and an exploiting device for exploiting said different qualities for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the different beams.
 27. A base station in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, comprising: a determining device for determining different beams with different qualities; and an exploiting device for exploiting said different qualities for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the different beams.
 28. A user equipment, in particular a mobile station, in a multi-beam transmission system, in particular a multi-beam MIMO system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, comprising: a determining device for determining different beams with different quality; and an exploiting device for exploiting said different qualities for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the different beams.
 29. A method for signaling channel quality information in a multi-beam transmission system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, the method comprising the steps of: determining, in the plurality of beams, a primary beam with a higher channel quality and at least one secondary beam with a different lower channel quality; and exploiting said higher and lower channel qualities for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the beams by providing a differential signaling relative to the primary beam to indicate the channel quality information value for the secondary beam(s), wherein an absolute value of the channel quality information is signaled for the primary beam, and the channel quality information values for the secondary beam(s) are signaled by means of an offset relative to the value for the primary beam.
 30. The method according to claim 29, wherein the offset is signaled at a lower update rate than the absolute channel quality information value for the primary beam.
 31. The method according to claim 30, wherein a lower update rate for the channel quality information transmissions relating to the secondary beam(s) compared to the update rate for the channel quality information transmissions relating to the primary beam is provided.
 32. The method according to claim 29, wherein for different beams, different cut-off thresholds are provided, below which a reporting of channel quality information is not required, and wherein a higher cut-off threshold is provided for the secondary beam(s) than for the primary beam.
 33. The method according to claim 32, wherein the cut-off thresholds are signaled from a network element to a user equipment, and wherein scheduled time instants are provided for the user equipment to transmit channel quality information to the network element, and when the user equipment estimates that the channel quality for a beam is below the respective cut-off threshold for that beam, the user equipment does not transmit channel quality information at the scheduled time instants until the channel quality is above the respective cut-off threshold.
 34. The method according to claim 32, wherein the cut-off thresholds are signaled from a network element to a user equipment, and wherein when the network element does not receive channel quality information at a scheduled time instant it does not make any further transmissions on the respective beam(s) until it receives a different channel quality information value from the user equipment.
 35. The method according to claim 29, wherein a coarser channel quality information quantization granularity is provided for the secondary beam(s) compared to the channel quality information quantization granularity applied to the channel quality information reports for the primary beam.
 36. Computer program product for carrying out a method according to claim
 29. 37. A multi-beam transmission system, wherein a plurality of beams are simultaneously transmitted and a plurality of sets of channel quality information are transmitted for controlling independently the transmission rate on the different beams, the multi-beam transmission system comprising: a determining device for determining in the plurality of beams, a primary beam with a higher channel quality and at least one secondary beam with a lower channel quality resulting in effects of errors in the channel quality information transmissions for the secondary beam(s) to be less significant than effects of errors in the channel quality information for the primary beam; and a reducing device for reducing a signaling overhead of the channel quality information for the beams based on said higher and lower channel qualities by providing a differential signaling means for indicating the channel quality information value for the secondary beam(s), wherein an absolute value of the channel quality information is signaled for the primary beam, and the channel quality information values for the secondary beam(s) are signaled by means of an offset relative to the value for the primary beam.
 38. A network element for a multi-beam transmission system as claimed in claim
 37. 39. A base station including at least a network element according to claim
 38. 40. A user equipment for a multi-beam transmission system as claimed in claim
 37. 